Philosophy on capital punishment essay

It is believed that by using the death penalty they are keeping the streets safe because "executed murders do not harm and murder again Sharp. Legal authorities have no right to allow such a situation but if they still choose to do so, it means that legal authorities contradict themselves.

His crime consists only in the unfair advantage… [taken] by breaking the law in question. First, the threat of punishment can deter potential offenders. Jeremy Bentham identified good with pleasure and evil with pain and held that the greatest pleasure should belong to the greatest number of people.

The general public traditionally supported the death penalty in a majority with only a few politicians speaking out against it i. Whether due to inherent vagaries of legal language, the necessity of discretion to judge properly complex, particular cases, the fallibility of human beings, or political pressures and other factors affecting decisions made within the system, such as clemency, the risk of error is not eliminable for the institution of capital punishment.

The innocent man did not rape the woman, so he does not deserve to be punished for that crime. Insulting the head of the state is the same as insulting the state itself. If something like that happens the person will not be able to fulfill legislative functions.

Incapacitation, Deterrence A utilitarian approach to capital punishment depends essentially on what are, in fact, the causal effects of the practice, whether the death penalty is, in fact, effective in incapacitating or deterring potential offenders.

Medical expertise needed for an execution itself can include administering medicines or psychiatric treatments to calm the condemned, judging whether intramuscular or intravenous techniques are best, or actually injecting a lethal dose of drugs to bring about a death Gaie, 1.

So in order to balance the scale of justice, it is necessary to inflict the deserved suffering on him. If, in fact, it does not effect these ends better than penal alternatives such as lengthy incarceration, then capital punishment is not justified on utilitarian grounds.

To carry out such a general project of constructing scales of crimes and matching punishments is a daunting challenge, as even many retributivists admit. One issue, then, is how high or low a recidivism rate decides the justificatory issue for capital punishment.

Capital Punishment

Furthermore, the sensible utilitarian will not attach much weight to the possibility that framing the man would stop the riots. If there were to be a real equivalence, the death penalty would have to be pronounced upon a criminal who had forewarned his victim of the very moment he would put him to a horrible death, and who, from that time on, had kept him confined at his own discretion for a period of months.

Capital Punishment

Throughout history and across different societies, criminals have been executed for a variety of offenses, but much of the literature is devoted to examining whether those convicted of murder ought to be executed, and this discussion will be similarly focused.

Its lack of popularity can be explained by noting a couple of objections.Thus far, then, it seems that the argument against capital punishment remains standing: it is not shown to be incoherent in the face of the desert and proportionality principles.

In tomorrow’s essay, I look at the question of political authority and capital punishment.


Philosophy - Capital Punishment. The Pros and Cons of Capital Punishment Essay - The Pros and Cons of Capital Punishment Since the mid ’s, capital punishment has brought many individuals into many diverse view points throughout the years.

The punishment plays a certain role in influencing the criminal's morals too (of course if it is not a capital punishment).


That's why the prisons are also called corrective or reformatory houses. In general it must be noted that Kant's doctrine on crime and punishment contains many valuable ideas on issues that are widely discussed in the.

- Capital Punishment loosely based assumption Capital punishment, also referred to as the death penalty, is the judicially ordered execution of a prisoner as a punishment for a serious crime, such as murder.

In Kant’s day, capital punishment was used for a variety of crimes through- out Europe and the new world, though Kant expressly argues in favor of it only for the crime of murder.

Essay: Arguments against the Death Penalty

Proponents of capital punishment also often claim that it deters potential murderers from crime in general and homicide in particular. In some public opinion polls, deterrence appears as the most often cited reason for supporting capital punishment.

Philosophy on capital punishment essay
Rated 5/5 based on 1 review